Vermont Senators Leahy and Sanders Honor Gov. Hoff

by Rich Cassidy on July 18, 2014

Post Updated with Video Clips from the Floor of the United States Senate

WASHINGTON, July 17 – In joint remarks before the U.S. Senate today, Sens. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) and Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) honored former Vermont Gov. Phil Hoff, who just turned 90 years old.

Hoff served three terms as governor. First elected in 1962, he was the first Democrat to hold the state’s highest office in more than a century.

“We rise today to celebrate Philip Hoff, the 73rd governor of the state of Vermont, for his extraordinary contributions to the state of Vermont, and to our nation,” Leahy and Sanders said in a joint statement submitted for the Congressional Record.

Here is the complete statement:

“Celebrating The 90th Birthday Of Vermont’s 73rd Governor, Phil Hoff”

“Mr. President, the Senior Senator from Vermont and I are pleased to call the Senate’s attention to a milestone in the life of a singular figure in the modern era of our state, former Governor Philip Hoff.

Phil Hoff, the 73rd Governor of the State of Vermont, made extraordinary contributions to the State of Vermont, and to our Nation. We join all Vermonters in wishing him well as he marks his 90th birthday.

Many view Phil Hoff as the founder of progressive politics in Vermont. His historical legacy to the state of Vermont, to New England, and to the Nation, is enormous.

Phil Hoff was an intrepid leader at a time when Vermont’s state government was in need of sweeping reform. Today, at a time when all too often “political courage” seems a contradiction in terms, we believe many of us would do well to look at the example Governor Hoff set while serving for three terms as Vermont’s governor. Phil Hoff always put the people of Vermont ahead of advancing his own career. Time and time again, he made decisions based on what he believed was right for the people of our state. He had a vision of a better and more just society, and he acted on that vision rather than on the basis of narrow political expediency. He was a leader, seeing the future and piloting Vermont toward it, always guided by a deep commitment to democratic practice and social justice.

His long career of public service began during World War II, when Phil Hoff put his studies on hold and joined the Navy, eventually joining the submarine service. Hoff served on the U.S.S. Sea Dog in the Pacific Theater, going on a number of combat tours in the dangerous waters near the main islands of Japan.

While in naval training in New London, Connecticut, a friend set him up on a blind date with a Connecticut College student. Her name was Joan Brower, and she and Phil would be married after the war, a marriage that was to last for six rich decades. Joan, in a variety of ways, including her strong efforts in fighting for quality education for Vermont youth, played an important role in Vermont.

After his graduation from Cornell Law School, Phil and Joan moved to Burlington, Vermont in 1951. Deeply committed to social justice, Hoff became involved in Democratic Party politics in the Green Mountain State, even though he grew up in a Republican family.

Phil Hoff was elected to the Vermont House of Representatives in 1960. He and a number of young freshman legislators, most of whom were under 40 and veterans of World War II, formed a group referred to by the press as the “Young Turks.” They worked together to breathe new life into the state Legislature and pass important reforms. This experience – both its hopes and its disappointments – motivated him to run for Governor in 1962.

For more than 100 years, the Republican Party dominated Vermont’s politics, controlling both houses of the Legislature and the governor’s office. Even in the landslide Presidential election of 1936, Vermont joined Maine as the only state that voted against President Roosevelt and his New Deal policies, leading to the revision of the old adage (referring to Maine being a bellwether state regarding presidential politics) from “As Maine goes, so goes the nation,” to “As Maine goes, so goes Vermont.”

A century of one-party rule left Vermont badly in need of reforms that could bring state government, the state’s education system, and the state’s economy into the second half of the 20th century.

Phil Hoff was not only a breath of fresh air, but a gale force of change. Governor Hoff achieved sweeping political reforms in a state where not much had changed in decades.

When he took office, the Vermont House of Representatives was still apportioned by town, meaning Burlington, with a population of over 40,000, had the same representation as some of the smaller towns around the state with populations of less than a hundred. Assisted by Supreme Court decisions that declared representation should be based on “one man, one vote,” Hoff pushed through legislation that apportioned House seats by population. In addition, Hoff successfully insisted on repealing Vermont’s poll tax, expanding access to voting for all Vermonters.

Governor Hoff made reforming the state’s education system a top priority. At the time, Vermont was undergoing a significant transformation, both demographically and economically. Phil Hoff quadrupled state aid to public schools, and organized the three state teachers colleges into a new, revitalized state college system that better met the needs of Vermont’s students. That system endures to this day and, with the addition of the state’s technical college and its extensive community college, is essential to the future of those seeking higher education.

Under Governor Hoff’s leadership, Vermont’s judicial system was modernized. Always a path breaker and an advocate for justice, Phil Hoff led the way to Vermont becoming one of the first states to abolish the death penalty.

No aspect of state government was beneath his notice, and he took Vermont forward in many ways, including terminating the outdated “Overseer of the Poor” system of welfare administration. He established the Vermont District Court state court system, the Judicial Nominating Board, the Vermont State Housing Authority, and the Vermont Student Assistance Corporation (VSAC).

Phil Hoff was a practical legislator, but he never relinquished his vision of a better future. Although some of his proposals were not enacted or realized during his administration, they formed the basis of future reform. After he left office, the sweeping reorganization of Vermont’s state government was finally enacted, largely along the lines that Hoff had envisioned. In addition, the land-use laws first proposed by Governor Hoff were later enacted, thus preserving Vermont’s rural landscape for future generations.

Governor Phil Hoff not only had vision, he had great political courage. His commitment to do what was right, and not just what was expedient, placed him in the nation’s leadership on the major issues of his time. Phil Hoff opposed the Vietnam War, long before it was easy to do so. He was the first governor to criticize the President’s policy of waging that increasingly endless war.

Phil Hoff took a strong stance fighting for civil rights. He formed a state civil rights commission. Concerned about racial justice, he co-founded the Vermont-New York Youth Project with New York City Mayor John Lindsay, which brought together minority students from the city and Vermont students to work together on summer projects at several Vermont colleges.

Though his commitment to civil rights, and to a less imperial foreign policy were highly controversial at the time, they created a sense – both in Vermont and in the nation – that Vermont could be a national leader in shaping a more just and peaceful society.

When, all over America, people turn to Vermont and see a small state leading the way in innovative health care, in energy efficiency, in the fight for social justice, in moving toward a progressive future instead of regressing into a past built out of reactionary fantasies, it is the legacy of Phil Hoff that they are encountering.
Vermonters today embody his example, and consistently move along the path that Phil blazed.

It is our great pleasure to call Philip Hoff a friend. For us he remains, always, an inspiration. Leading Vermont into the contemporary era, he redefined our state and established the foundation for Vermont to become a national leader on issues, ranging from health care and education to the environment to civil rights.

In his first inaugural address as governor of Vermont, Phil Hoff said, “The people of Vermont have clearly said that they don’t want to continue with the old ways, and if we fail to respond to forces at work in our society, we face a bleak future.” Those words, true then, are still true today. Phil Hoff, an inspiration then, remains an inspiration today.”

Contacts: Michael Briggs (Sanders) 202-224-5141
David Carle (Leahy): 202-224-3693

Senators Leahy and Sanders Honor Phil and Joan on the Floor of the United State Senate:


ULCLogoThe Uniform Law Commission begins its 2014 Annual Meeting on Thursday July 11, 2014 at the Westin Hotel in Seattle, Washington. Meeting in its 123rd year, the Commission, also known as the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Law, faces a challenging agenda.

More than 270 lawyers, judges and law professors — appointed as Commissioners by their home states and territories — are gathering in the sparkling City of Seattle under blue skies and unseasonably warm temperatures, to confer on and promulgate uniform state laws for presentation and consideration by state legislatures on subjects where it would be useful for state law to be the same or similar from state to state.

Representatives of organizations that the ULC works with on a regular basis, including the Uniform Law Conference of Canada, the Mexican Uniform Law Commission, the American Bar Association, the American Law Institute, the National Association of Attorneys General, the National Association of Secretaries of State, the National Conference of State Legislatures, the National Council of State Governments, the Conference of Chief Justices and National Center for State Courts, and the United States Department of State, will also likely attend.

A number of Proposed Uniform Acts will be presented for first or interim readings:

Those Acts will likely be presented again for line-by-line reading at the 2015 ULC Annual Meeting in Williamsburg, Virginia, before final ULC promulgation as Uniform or Model Acts.

Four acts are scheduled to be presented for final readings, and presumably will be presented for approval by a roll call vote of the states on Wednesday July 16, 2014: Seattle-Space-Needle-7410

The meeting is scheduled to adjourn on Thursday, July 17, 2014.

This year at the August meeting of the Uniform Law Commission of Canada in Toronto, Ontario, the Canadian Law Conference will consider its own, parallel version of the Uniform Recognition of Substitute Decision-Making Documents Act.



Thank You to the Barre Historical Society and the Vermont Labor History Society for Celebrating Phil and Joan Hoff

June 30, 2014

In 1962, I lived with my parents in Rutland, Vermont. One day early in the fall, I was at home, out sick from school. I was nine years old. There was a knock at the front door. Although I was in my pajamas, I raced to answer it. I opened the door and found an […]

Read the full article →

“Dogs Have Their Rights,” But Does Every Dog Get One Bite?

June 16, 2014

In talking about liability claims and dog bite cases, it’s often said that “every dog gets one bite.” I know of no Vermont Supreme Court case that literally applies that rule, but it is the conventional wisdom. And it seems to be the rule of thumb applied by insurance adjusters: if the dog has a […]

Read the full article →

The Signing Ceremony H. 413, the Vermont Uniform Collateral Consequences of Conviction Act

June 13, 2014

The signing ceremony for H. 413, the Vermont Uniform Collateral Consequences of Conviction Act, is now available. Here it is:   Rich

Read the full article →

The Vermont Uniform Collateral Consequences of Conviction Act Becomes Law

June 11, 2014

In a Statehouse ceremony yesterday, Vermont Governor Peter Shumlin signed H. 413, the Vermont Uniform Collateral Consequences of Conviction Act. Governor Shumlin thanked the many who were involved in the getting the legislation passed, and noted that it was part of a trend towards creating a smart criminal justice system. I took a moment to […]

Read the full article →

Farewell Mr. Wilson: Live Long and Prosper!

June 1, 2014

Some dozen years ago, my law partners and I were looking for a paralegal. As we sifted through the resumes, one stood out. A fifty-something lawyer with fifteen years’ experience in Louisiana and Texas had applied for our paralegal job. Some were dubious. We were looking for a paralegal, not an experienced lawyer.  He was […]

Read the full article →

The American Law Institute Approves Collateral Consequences Provisions in Model Penal Code Revision: Radical Reform or Back to the Future?

May 27, 2014

Today we are honored to have a Guest Post by Margaret Colgate Love: It appears that the day has finally come when collateral consequences are understood to be part and parcel of the criminal justice system, not dismissed as civil regulatory matters of no concern to prosecutors, defense lawyers, and courts. This was confirmed by […]

Read the full article →

There are Dog Cases and Then There are Dog Cases

May 19, 2014

When I started as an associate in a law firm there was a semi-retired partner who was in of counsel status. I was warned to avoid him because he would assign me to handle a “dog case.” It was meant in a pejorative sense: a case that never should have been taken and was now […]

Read the full article →

Clarence Darrow and a Healthy Dose of Determinism

May 12, 2014

I have always been interested in Clarence Darrow. I suppose it stems from my own natural tendency to be an underdog rooter. If I turn on the television and two sports teams that I don’t follow are competing, I always favor the team that is behind. But admiration does not come easy to me, as […]

Read the full article →